bradford_h
September 1st, 2005, 05:01 PM
Hi all-
Is anyone else watching this show? It's on the Discovery Channel, Tuesday & Friday evenings.
To my mind it's relevant to any effort we make in trying to understand the Early Zhou authors of the Yi, and shows anthropology the way it should be done - by getting to know the people instead of standing back and projecting our objectivities on them.
Much of the conflicts in modern Yi scholarship concern the relative importance of cultural evolution on a people's understanding of normal human behavior and social interaction. The academics will tend to argue that less modern cultures are severely impoverished in these areas, relative to us, and extremely superstition ridden in most aspects of life. I have argued that we have a great deal more in common, in these areas at least, and that these are the very areas of life that the Zhouyi is most concerned with.
I think this show is a delight. The host has some real courage - he truly dares to cross the great stream, in the sense that it's used in Gua 13.
Is anyone else watching this show? It's on the Discovery Channel, Tuesday & Friday evenings.
To my mind it's relevant to any effort we make in trying to understand the Early Zhou authors of the Yi, and shows anthropology the way it should be done - by getting to know the people instead of standing back and projecting our objectivities on them.
Much of the conflicts in modern Yi scholarship concern the relative importance of cultural evolution on a people's understanding of normal human behavior and social interaction. The academics will tend to argue that less modern cultures are severely impoverished in these areas, relative to us, and extremely superstition ridden in most aspects of life. I have argued that we have a great deal more in common, in these areas at least, and that these are the very areas of life that the Zhouyi is most concerned with.
I think this show is a delight. The host has some real courage - he truly dares to cross the great stream, in the sense that it's used in Gua 13.