...life can be translucent

Menu

Very Basic Question

crystal_blue

visitor
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
Is Yin the absence of Yang (or vice-versa), or are they entities in their own right?
 
H

hmesker

Guest
The one can never be the absence of the other. If you say yin, you automatically imply yang. You can only name something yin if you compare it to something else. That 'something else' must be yang. We call the night dark because the day is light. If there wouldn't be 'day' we would never call the night 'dark' - we just wouldn't know any better. In other words, when you say yin there must be yang. Somewhere.

Is man the absence of woman?

Harmen.
 

crystal_blue

visitor
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
The one can never be the absence of the other. If you say yin, you automatically imply yang. You can only name something yin if you compare it to something else. That 'something else' must be yang. We call the night dark because the day is light. If there wouldn't be 'day' we would never call the night 'dark' - we just wouldn't know any better. In other words, when you say yin there must be yang. Somewhere.

I mean, is saying X is Yin identical to saying X is not Yang (and, by extension, meaning that only Yang need be defined)? Although, when phrased like that, it does seem to degenerate into a linguistics anomally...
 
H

hmesker

Guest
I mean, is saying X is Yin identical to saying X is not Yang (and, by extension, meaning that only Yang need be defined)?

No, it does not work like that, because hardly ever is something only yin or yang, in most cases it is a mixture, just as in the Yijing: there are only two hexagrams which are pure yin or yang, the other 62 are a mixture of yin and yang. Saying that something is yin or yang is an estimate, a convention, or a compromise. In daily life there hardly is anything yin or yang.

Harmen.
 

crystal_blue

visitor
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
No, it does not work like that, because hardly ever is something only yin or yang, in most cases it is a mixture, just as in the Yijing: there are only two hexagrams which are pure yin or yang, the other 62 are a mixture of yin and yang.

Again, though, isn't saying 'X is 40% Yang and 60% Yin', for example, identical to saying 'X is 40% Yang', therefore Yin is merely a measure of how 'Yang deficient' something is?
 
H

hmesker

Guest
Again, though, isn't saying 'X is 40% Yang and 60% Yin', for example, identical to saying 'X is 40% Yang', therefore Yin is merely a measure of how 'Yang deficient' something is?

If you focus on one limited aspect of something I think you could say that. But let's take a black marble. Marbles are round, and 'round' is an aspect of yang. But the colour is black, and 'black' is an aspect of yin. So, is a black marble yin or yang?

Harmen.
 
B

bruce_g

Guest
Is Yin the absence of Yang (or vice-versa), or are they entities in their own right?

It's an interesting question, one I tend to move along with rather than against. I can understand what Harmen is saying, and your question remains valid also.

If, for example, Yin can be expressed as void, then the absence of Yang determines the quantity of Yin. But since Yin can not be quantified (how do you measure a void except by the absence of something?), how can it be measured unless measured according to the quantity of Yang? ... which it seems is what Harmen was expressing.

I think the earth's tides express the nature of Yin and Yang. We can get our heads around the fact that the tide rises here because of the absence of it there, and vv. Likewise, the moon waxes and wanes according to the measure of each other - which again is what Harmen implied: one can not exist without the other. But I see no contradiction in the question you are asking.

I've pondered your question myself. Philosophically, I have rationalized it through a prose of hex. 1 and 2, as follows:

Yang - Hex. 1
In the beginning was the Urge. It knew neither light nor dark, forward nor back. Neither did it know good or evil. Source of endless possibilities; the Urge always finds his way to become.

Yin - Hex. 2
Before the beginning was space for creation. Devoted and strong, open yet firm: Heaven’s wife receives the seed and bears upon herself all things manifest.

It doesn't answer your question, it just presents it in a different way. How can each be measured but by the absence of the other?
 
Last edited:

crystal_blue

visitor
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
If you focus on one limited aspect of something I think you could say that. But let's take a black marble. Marbles are round, and 'round' is an aspect of yang. But the colour is black, and 'black' is an aspect of yin. So, is a black marble yin or yang?

A black marble is partly Yang?
 
B

bruce_g

Guest
The earth is also round. But isn't the earth Yin and heaven Yang? :mischief:
 

crystal_blue

visitor
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
I think the earth's tides express the nature of Yin and Yang. We can get our heads around the fact that the tide rises here because of the absence of it there, and vv. Likewise, the moon waxes and wanes according to the measure of each other...

Aren't they governed by some external factor (gravitional pull, source of light), rather than determining themselves as it were?

Yin - Hex. 2
Before the beginning was space for creation.

How can there be something before the beginning? I suppose it could be the end of something else...

It doesn't answer your question, it just presents it in a different way. How can each be measure but by the absence of the other?

Thank you for your response. You too, Harmen.
- :)
 
B

bruce_g

Guest

Like a womb?

DDJ:
Before the universe was born
there was something in the chaos of the heavens.
It stands alone and empty,
solitary and unchanging.
It is ever present and secure.
It may be regarded as the Mother of the universe.
Because I do not know it's name,
I call it the Tao.
If forced to give it a name,
I would call it 'Great'.
 

toganm

visitor
Joined
May 30, 2006
Messages
139
Reaction score
2
The earth is also round. But isn't the earth Yin and heaven Yang? :mischief:

Not the Chinese of that era when it was square. By the way mankind standing on the Earth is yang compared to Earth, however since also under Heaven mankind is yin in relationship to Heaven.
;)

Togan
 

crystal_blue

visitor
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
By the way mankind standing on the Earth is yang compared to Earth, however since also under Heaven mankind is yin in relationship to Heaven.

Is a black marble less Yang when surrounded by white marbles?
 

Sparhawk

One of those men your mother warned you about...
Clarity Supporter
Joined
Sep 17, 1971
Messages
5,120
Reaction score
107
The earth is also round. But isn't the earth Yin and heaven Yang? :mischief:

Now it is, and it comes from simple observation, but for the Chinese of antiquity, Earth was square and Heaven round. Now, who can actually confirm that Heaven, in all its immensity, is round?? :D

L
 

Sparhawk

One of those men your mother warned you about...
Clarity Supporter
Joined
Sep 17, 1971
Messages
5,120
Reaction score
107
Oops, I didn't see Toganm's reply before shooting mine... :rofl:

L
 

Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom

Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).

Top