Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).
Firstly, there is no problem about asking questions how others are, think, feel etc
If we disallow these types of questions then there would be hardly any questions to give answer to, all the divinatory forums would just cease to exist. The majority of people ask about other people so just go with the flow and relax, as there is no privacy in this world anymore and never will be.
First of all, am sorry if that thread was a disrespect to the Yi, but I never meant it that way. There are many oracles apart from the Yi that people use to ask about another.
Tarot, psychics, runes, astrology and numerology. It may be a disrespect if one actually knows what the hexagrams mean. But for the poor others who really don't, one question is as good as another. I don't think you will understand, but it is this way for me.
I am an astrologer more than an Yi-reader, so I don't think I can be blamed if I ask too many questions that irritate you. To the seasoned Yi reader, one hexagram tells all. but to the clueless, as I said before, it may look like greek.
I don't think the yi minds students using it's hexagrams to learn, moreso about their personal lives. We all learn about the oracles this way, some more than others. I don't think those who claim a holy attitude haven't had their curiousity peaked enough to ask a revealing question.
.Also, you don't know my situation, and to make an assumption (Trojan), isn't much better. People are complicated and if the yi can help some, I say go for it.
Now I took everything with a pinch of salt, although willowfox was mostly right. The basis of oracles would be that they offer a touch of mystery
Those who know, do. As long as no-one is harmed, why not? Personally I wouldn't choose to place a personal life story for anyone to criticise or laugh at, but I knew that was one consequence. Further I feel it would help in understanding the hexes because some of it may definitely be wrong and are.
By the way, if I truly understood the first hexagram I got, I would not have any more incentive to ask
Yes sure everyone asks questions about others sometimes but when it comes down to assessing someones motives, guessing an answer on that then making another question based on another piece of guesswork, and then making another assumption on another piece of guess work it just gets ridiculous when the querant themselves hasn't actually got a clue what their answers mean and starts believing or appearing to believe someone here like
did he steal the brooch ? -yes
why did he steal it ...blah blah
how did he feel about stealing it..blah blah
what does he think i think about him stealing it...blah blah
will he steal again...blah blah
by this time we have a complex picture of a theif who may become a hardened criminal except ...he didn't steal the brooch in the first place so all those following questions were based on a false assumption..due to not understanding the Yi was not going to answer your first question , it was talking about you because what you asked was not your business.
So, your suggestion is that if they don't tell me something, I should just accept it. Well it's not that easy especially if much trust, friendship and love is involved.
I was pretty gobsmacked to find Hilary recommending this thread in the friends notes she sends http://www.onlineclarity.co.uk/friends/showthread.php?t=5664
Jesed, if only I could have an amount of blind trust for someone.
That girl is no longer my friend, and i wonder if she's ever been.
as for your partner... hmm, would love to trust him, and i'm still finding out if I should.
If I do and he's not to be trusted, who's the fool? I've been burned before and will certainly not allow it again.
Well, the way I see friendship is like a free-space, where I'm not obligated to perfome some kind of emotional-striptease. And yes, I some times need to kept silence about something with my friends; and respect my firend's silences.you wouldnt keep a secret and be open from a friend, would you, especially if it involves them for years?
I think it's natural that you should want to ask the I-Ching about others - because that is what occupies most people's thoughts and emotions isn't it?
Well it does mine, and maybe that's a weakness?
marie, I appreciate your semi sarcasm, but then I already knew that, nobody needed to tell me.
I don't. You asked me something; I answered you. That's allToo bad jesed, that you feel the need to justify your friendships to me.
Not at all. Diferent doesn't implies (in me) better or worse; just diferent"But again, diferent people react in diferent ways" - Seems to imply yours is the better of the ways
Trojan, in defense of myself, you don't know my situation with my guy friend. I did mention in my threads that I tried to ask him but he always evades me. So I did ask.
I don't think you'd want to know any more about my personal life with them, but i'll just say that this is not a one off thing as you know. Some people love the status quo and if a couple of years won't do it, put in a couple more.
I feel it is justified for me prying into his or their lives to preserve my own sanity. If this is unethical and deserves a karmic payback then this prying is theirs. If I will have mine i willingly accept it because this is my choice. afterall what i know about the Yi is that it follows natural laws and so cause and effect here applies. The Yi apparently doesn't give me the hexagram 4 much, which I will take as a sign to stop.
So, your suggestion is that if they don't tell me something, I should just accept it. Well it's not that easy especially if much trust, friendship and love is involved. I want to know the truth, and I think it's justified for me to find all means to have it. I wouldn't say what Wfox and all of you experts here say is the truth (who would want to carry that burden of omni-knowledge-potence?) certainly not me, for the consequences are huge. That is why there's a huge disclaimer "For entertainment purposes" even though it is clearly not.
Well ordinarily, a gift or token means something, so I didn't outright call him a theif and would brush it off if not for the other girl's overt nastiness towards me. Now why would she be nasty to me, I think? Is it related to the gift?
that is how I formulated my questions. I like to see what the Yi says and I don't see anything wrong with that. Even if it's interpreted wrongly, no matter, because then I see there is another facet to that hexagram.
.
Yes, exactly. I was pointing to the 'speed reading' aspect. (If there are outstanding readings going on that I'm missing when I compile the links, use the rating system to make sure they get seen!) Also I notice by no means all of the questions on that thread are in the 'invasion of privacy' category: there's plenty of 'what if?' and 'how can I?'I think Hilary chose the thread because it has multitude hexagrams all interpreted concisely by willowfox.
Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).