Skip to content

I Ching with Clarity

For some 3,000 years, people have turned to the I Ching, the Book of Changes, to help them uncover the meaning of their experience, to bring their actions into harmony with their underlying purpose, and above all to build a foundation of confident awareness for their choices.

Down the millennia, as the I Ching tradition has grown richer and deeper, the things we consult about may have changed a little, but the moment of consultation is much the same. These are the times when you’re turning in circles, hemmed in and frustrated by all the things you can’t see or don’t understand. You can think it over (and over, and over); you can ‘journal’ it; you can gather opinions.

But how can you have confidence in choosing a way to go, if you can’t quite be sure of seeing where you are?

Only understand where you are now, and you rediscover your power to make changes. This is the heart of I Ching divination. Once you can truly see into the present moment, all its possibilities open out before you – and you are free to create your future.

What is the I Ching?

The I Ching (or Yijing) is an oracle book: it speaks to you. You can call on its help with any question you have: issues with relationships of all kinds, ways to attain your personal goals, the outcomes of different choices for a key decision. It grounds you in present reality, encourages you to grow, and nurtures your self-knowledge. When things aren’t working, it opens up a space for you to get ‘off the ride’, out of the rut, and choose your own direction. And above all, it’s a wide-open, free-flowing channel for truth.

For I Ching beginners

How do you want to get started?

There are two different ways most people first meet the I Ching. There’s,

‘I’m fascinated by this ancient book and I want to learn all about it,’

and there’s,

‘I need help now with this thing (so I’ll learn whatever I need to know to get help with The Thing).’

Learning about the I Ching, or learning from the I Ching?

In the end, these two ways aren’t actually different. It isn’t possible to do one without the other, and people end up wanting both: after your first reading, your curiosity will probably be aroused – and you’ll draw on Yi’s help more as your knowledge of it grows.

But… they are different at the beginning:

Get the I Ching’s help:

(There’s help at hand to explain how it works.)

If you’d like my help, have a look at the I Ching reading services.

Learn the I Ching:

It has all you need to get started from scratch. Then when you’re familiar with the basics and want to develop your confidence in interpretation, have a look at the Foundations Course.

Not a beginner?

Welcome – I’m glad you’ve come. Let’s explore this extraordinary oracle together!

Clarity’s here to help you deepen, explore and enjoy your relationship with Yi. You might like…

Reflections on readings, hexagrams, trigrams, imagery, myth, hidden structures…

Diving into real I Ching readings, relishing the way the oracle dissolves barriers between spiritual connection and ordinary life – listen and subscribe here.

where you can get to know some like-minded Yi-enthusiasts. To participate in the conversation and keep in touch, do join Clarity.

Hello, and thank you for visiting!

I’m Hilary – I work as an I Ching diviner and teacher, and I’m the author of I Ching: Walking your path, creating your future.

I hope you enjoy the site and find what you’re looking for here – do contact me with any comments or questions.

Clarity is my one-woman business providing I Ching courses, readings and community. (You can read more about me, and what I do, here.) It lets me spend my time doing the work I love, using my gifts to help you.

(Thank you.)

Warm wishes,
Hilary”

Hilary Barrett

Blog

More at home with mandate

Introducing ming

I've started exploring an interesting word in the Yi, one of those that's so heavily freighted with Deep Significance that it can be hard to know what to do with it.

Ming 命 - 'mandate' (amongst other things) - occurs in 6.4, 7.2.6, 11.6, 12.4, 49.4, 56.5, where it has many different translations. In Wilhelm/Baynes, it's 'fate', a 'decoration' (from the king), 'commands', 'the form of government', and 'office'. How can a single word mean all these things?

Here it is:

ming

A mouth (probably) is calling down to a kneeling figure - this part of the character is ling, 'to give orders'. During Zhou times, scribes started adding the mouth at the bottom left to differentiate ming from ling.

The dictionary defines this as orders, to command someone, to give them a mission or responsibility. To receive or accept ming from heaven is to be invested with authority and become a successful ruler; the ruler himself also issues ming that are royal decrees and come with official insignia.

From here, the word has also developed more philosophical/metaphysical meanings: your lifespan, your lot in life, the fate bestowed on you by heaven; also your innate qualities, the gifts bestowed on you by heaven, and the concomitant duty to fulfil them.

A very useful English word to capture this idea is calling - and this is also a very good fit for that ancient character with its mouth speaking to the figure below. 'Your mission, should you choose to accept it...' (You should.)

The Mandate of Heaven, 天命

The concept of a Mandate of Heaven, tianming, seems to originate with the Zhou - the people who crafted the Yi. According to this idea, kingship is not an innate right; it is a calling from Heaven. To be worthy of such a calling, the ruler must be virtuous, and govern justly and well. If he is incompetent or corrupt, he will forfeit the Mandate, and there will be signs - celestial omens, natural disasters - indicating the loss.

The clearest sign of all would be a successful rebellion. If a people have overthrown the old regime and founded a new one, then by definition the Mandate of Heaven must have passed to them - without it, they would have failed.

The Tuanzhuan - the Commentary on the Oracle - of Hexagram 49 lays it out:

"Tang and Wu changed the mandates
Complying with heaven while resonating with humanity."

Bradford Hatcher's translation

Wu (son of Wen) overthrew the Shang. Tang was the first Shang ruler, who established their dynasty by overthrowing the Xia some 550 years before.

It's essential to pay constant, careful, humble attention to the signs of this Mandate, and not presume. King Wu, after gathering all the armies in the Wilds of Mu, read the signs (Jupiter turning retrograde, according to Pankenier in Astrology and Cosmology in Early China) and insisted on turning back, in the teeth of his generals' eagerness to advance. 'You do not know Heaven's Mandate,' he told them. 'It may not yet be done.' And even when you have received the Mandate, it could still easily be lost - an idea I think is reflected in Hexagram 63's anxiety about chaotic endings.

However... tianming, the Mandate of Heaven, doesn't actually get a mention in the Zhouyi (the oldest layers of the Yijing text) - only ming. So not every occurrence of the word has to be weighed down with the full meaning of heaven's mandate. Perhaps some of them are simply 'orders'?

For comparison, we can look at the inscription on this bronze vessel, the Da Yu Ding, which is more or less contemporary with the Yi itself. The word ming appears here several times, and the translation shows its range of meanings: the Mandate of Heaven, as forfeited by Yin (the Shang) and received by Zhou, but also the detailed 'charge' that the king is making to his subordinate Yu, who casts this vessel to record it - and, perhaps, to ensure Heaven will hear about it when the inscribed vessel is used for offerings.

So even on this most solemn occasion, the casting of a great bronze vessel, not every ming comes direct from heaven. In the Yi, in readings (which are for any and all occasions!), we have to allow a broader meaning: calling, what you are charged to do, your responsibility.

Could ming be trivial, everyday 'orders' - the latest unreasonable email from the boss? Perhaps. But it's worth noting that the Yi does have different ways to describe this: the 'charge' embraced in 12.2 (Bradford Hatcher translated that firmly as 'servitude'), and 'affairs' or 'work' (not least when it's 'the king's work', as in 2.3 or 6.3). I don't think ming will ever just be the prosaic 'stuff you have to get done'.

Instead of arguing: 6.4

'Cannot master this argument,
Returning and taking up the mandate.
With a change of heart, peaceful constancy is good fortune.'

In its first appearance, we get to understand mandate by seeing what it isn't: the unwinnable argument. When you can't win, you turn yourself around (this is the same 'return' as the name of Hexagram 24) and take up the mandate.

This amounts to, or calls for, a 'change of heart' - something I've written about before): this line is one vertex of a triangle of 'changes of heart', along with 16.6 and 17.1.

'Enthusiasm in the dark.
Results bring a change of heart,
No mistake.'
'An official has a change of heart.
Constancy, good fortune.
Going out of the gates, joining with others, there is achievement.'

A 'change of heart' can come from encountering results after a whole hexagram of anticipation, or from going out of the gates from the confines of your official seat - or from turning away from the argument. In each case, it seems to be a change towards something bigger and more real.

It's also interesting to compare this one with line 2:

'Cannot master this argument,
Return home, escape to your town's people,
Three hundred households.
No blunder.'

Recognising the unwinnable at an earlier stage, back at line 2, you turn back towards familiar relationships and can at least avoid the blind stupidity of fighting a losing battle. But line 4 has an actively positive omen: with peaceful constancy, good fortune. How come?

Where second lines tend to be focussed on relationships, fourth lines, just across the boundary between trigrams, tend to ask, 'What can I do here?' Asking this question mid-argument means learning very thoroughly that no, you can't win this, but here's how you can be at home in life ('peaceful', an 安, originally shows a woman under a roof) in a quiet, steady way: by turning back to your mandate. By definition, it's the perfect opposite of an unwinnable argument: what you can do, because it is exactly what's yours to do. While only line 5 of Hexagram 6 can win the argument, line 4 enjoys good fortune from not winning.

This line changes to Hexagram 59: it's Arguing's moment of Dispersing. Why can't you win? Perhaps you are arguing with the floods: not much future in that, as King Canute demonstrated. Or perhaps the position you were fighting for loses definition by itself. The win/lose binary dissolves, the flow of spiritual energy is no longer blocked (its default state in Hexagram 6), and you can rejoin it by settling peacefully into your calling.

(Six more examples to come...)

Inner Truth Dispersing

Back in January 2025, I had a good conversation with Tasha and Jeff of the Mind Bod Adventure Pod - a podcast with a truly intriguing archive of in-depth conversations. We talked Yi, and discussed a reading:

Question: "What do Tasha and Jeff and everyone listening need to know about the I Ching?"

Answer: Hexagram 61, Inner Truth, changing at line 1 to 59, Dispersing.

Here's the recording. (I'm not completely sure how this 'embedded' link will work, but you probably need to click 'Read on Substack' to watch it.)

The I Ching: An Ancient Oracle | Hilary Barrett by Tasha Schumann

On divination, inner truth, and questions for a 3,000-year-old oracle

Read on Substack


Being a composer...

Daniel asked the oracle to talk to him about being a composer, and received Hexagram 57, Subtly Penetrating, changing at line 5 to 18, Corruption:

changing to

And this has an intriguing relationship to the reading in last month's episode, about being a storyteller - 58.2 to 17:

changing to

I hope you enjoy this one!

Hexagram 48: another visit to the Well

After going one step at a time through the Oracle texts of hexagrams 40 and 59, I thought I'd try the same with Hexagram 48, the Well. This is not the first time I've revisited this hexagram, and probably won't be the last. I suppose that's to be expected! ('They come and go, the well wells.')

I've been reading through the Oracle text again, trying to understand how it unfolds line by line:

'The Well. Moving the city, not moving the well.
Without loss, without gain,
They come and go, the well wells.
Almost drawn the water, but the rope does not quite reach the water,
Or breaking one's clay jug,
Pitfall.'

Moving the city, not moving the well.

井
改邑不改井

The well.
Moving the city, not moving the well.

This first statement is starting to sound to me like a riddle. Hold on a minute... we built our city, and we built our well. Both are built, both are ours. How come one of these things can be moved, but not the other?

This might be a good moment to pause and understand what 'moving the city' means. Both in Zhou times and before, Chinese settlements sometimes had to be moved. There are many possible reasons for this: fields losing fertility, creeping drought that drove people south over generations, encroaching hostile tribes. It seems it was generally understood as something required of the people by Heaven.

In the Shangshu, the Book of Documents, you can read the story of a Shang king, Pan Geng, working to persuade his people of the need to move. (Here it is, in Legge's translation: parts 1, 2 and 3.) It's immediately apparent that this move was a major undertaking, one that meant immediate hardship for quite distant long-term gain. The people would take their livestock, sacred objects, weapons and tools, leave their homes and rebuild from scratch - including, of course, digging a new well.

The Oracle text of this hexagram doesn't say 'a city can be moved, a well cannot be moved.' There is a word for 'possible to' or 'capable of' in the Yi, and it's not found here. So it seems to me this is not just a theoretical contemplation of what's possible - it's more likely that it mentions moving cities because a city is being moved. A change is happening, or called for, and it's hard work. Time to understand the difference between all the things that change, and the one thing that doesn't.

So what exactly does it mean to say that the well doesn't move? The city's buildings - heavy timbers on rammed earth walls - aren't going to be moved, either. They, like the well, are left behind.

However, you can rebuild them exactly as they were, wherever you choose. What you cannot move is the place where a well can be dug. A well isn't a building; it's an opening. Minford compares the possible sites for a well - those places where conditions are good and the water table is high enough - to acupuncture points on the human body. I find that a wonderfully rich comparison. The site for the well is there before anyone starts digging.

You can move your whole life - from the royal court to the family pig - but you can't move the contours of bedrock and water table. No wonder Pan Geng had to overcome so much reluctance among his people: as well as moving everything, they were going to have to discover and dig new wells - a whole different kind of work.

This starts to give me a different sense of Hexagram 48 in readings. Wherever you are, you have to find a way to connect to what sustains you. You may have a lot of work to do on the horizontal axis, as it were, moving from point A to point B across the surface - but there is also this vertical axis, the need to rediscover and renew your connection to source, and this is a different kind of thing altogether. More 'moving' activity will not help.

Without loss, without gain

无喪无得。

I don't believe this means that the water level in the well never varies. The water level in a well does rise and fall, and in a hard drought, the well might dry up altogether.

Besides, the words translated here as 'loss' and 'gain' aren't associated with having less or more of something, but with whether you have it at all.

They first appear, together, in the Oracle of Hexagram 2:

'Fruitful in the south and west, gaining partners.
In the east and north, losing partners.'

You could also lose sheep at Yi, lose a horse (don't chase it!), not lose the sacred ladle, lose coins, or a servant, or money and an axe, or the carriage curtain. According to the dictionary, you could lose troops, or livestock, or the support of the people, or your life; the oldest meanings involve mourning at a funeral.

'Gain' might be better translated simply as 'get': the ancient character shows a hand grasping a cowrie shell (used as currency before coins). In the Yi, you might get allies, or honour, or a metal arrowhead.

'Without loss, without gain' seems to me to be a way of offering immediate reassurance for the insecure, uncertain business of moving the city.

I need my well! I can't live without it! What do you mean, I can't take it with me?

No, you can't take the well with you, but that doesn't mean you've lost it. It isn't something you can lose.

It also isn't something you can get. (You can't go to the market and trade for a new well, or become rich by stockpiling wells.)

'This is our house that we built.'
'This is our well that we built.'
And yet it wasn't built in the same way, and we don't own it in the same way.

In readings, all this is a powerful invitation to reflect on what sustains us, what we think of casually as 'ours', without ever owning it at all. Hexagram 48 famously represents the Yi itself. I've often seen it representing mental health and emotional resilience - and most recently (in a reading recorded for a future podcast episode), it stood for someone's family.

Go come well well

往來井井

I love the poetic economy of this line. Go-come, a pair of opposites, two words on their way to becoming one, representing coming-and-going, the passage of time, exchange and relationships. Well-well: 'the well is the well' (Bradford Hatcher); 'the well wells' (me); 'it remains the same well, pure and still' (R.J.Lynn).

This is the perfect, perfectly succinct reassurance. You can't move the well, but there's no need. In all your comings and goings, the well is always present.

However...

汔至

Nearly arrived/reached

亦未繘井

And-also not well-rope/drawing water well

(This is universally translated as 'the rope does not reach the water'.)

羸其瓶。凶。

Breaking the jug. Disaster.

There seems to be a heavy emphasis on how that well-rope is nearly long enough. As a 'cellist, it reminds me of being nearly in tune (another way of saying 'out of tune'): it sounds like someone making an excuse. If you nearly reached the water, you are still just as thirsty.

The broken pitcher is a different failure mode, and perhaps even more frustrating: it reached the water, touched the potential, but can't draw it all the way up into use.

The well is a strange, unique thing: you can't hold it, move it, or lose it; it is always present, underlying and unaffected by all your changes. However, this does not mean 'it's always there for you' no matter what you do. Reaching what it offers is a constant challenge - it's just that the work of reaching it is quite unlike any other work, one at right-angles to regular busy-ness.

Entertaining synchronicity

A reminder that readings, and the synchronicities that surround them, can simply be fun. Here's a reading, about making both an income and a difference, that certainly is: Hexagram 58, Opening, changing at line 2 to 17, Following:

changing to

‘Lakes joined together. Opening.
A noble one joins with friends to speak and practise together.’

Into the image

The Yi talks in images: hexagram shapes, trigram pictures, sometimes the original forms of the Chinese words themselves, and - most clearly - in its vignettes and stories. When you're just getting started with readings, those are the images you can't miss.

You might ask...
'How to start a conversation to help this decision along?'

And Yi might answer with,

'Coming slowly, slowly,
Confined in a bronze chariot.
Shame.
There is completion.'

(Hexagram 47, line 4)

or,

'Your wheels dragged back.
Constancy, good fortune.'

(Hexagram 64, line 2)

Of course you would read the whole hexagram and the relating hexagram to set this in context, not just your moving line! But this post is just about how you'd engage with the imagery, so I'll zoom in.

What's the first thing to do with an answer like this?

Not 'look up the commentary to tell you what it means.'

Also not 'ask AI to tell you what it means.' I think this can be extra-tempting because while it's hard for the wording of a pre-written commentary to fit all possible questions, if you feed your situation and question into the AI it will spit out a wholly personalised answer. And it will probably do a reasonable job of interpreting the image and turning it into advice about your conversation - AI can be surprisingly good with metaphor.

So why not just go straight to the end result, save a lot of time and effort, and find out what your reading means?

Well - by analogy - if I wanted to transform my cardiovascular fitness, I could train for a marathon. (There is exactly zero chance of this ever happening, but just for the sake of the comparison...) But why not just go straight to the end result, save a lot of time and effort, and buy a marathon completion medal on eBay?

That's not a wonderful analogy (connecting with imagery is actually fun), but hopefully you see what I mean: it would be pointless to get the appearance of the end result without having undergone the transformation. And with Yi, inside the imagery is where the transformation happens.

A good first step is to shelve the whole issue of what the image means, how to make sense of it, and what it's telling you about your question. Instead, you set out to get a feel for it.

Possibly my favourite way to do this is to ask tremendously simple questions about the image itself.

'Coming slowly, slowly,
Confined in a bronze chariot.
Shame.
There is completion.'

What's it like to be confined in a bronze chariot?

Stuffy, I think, and cramped. I can't feel the ground under my feet, I can't stop to take in my surroundings, or speed up and feel my muscles working.

What's a chariot? What's it for?

It's a vehicle. It's to get me to my destination - not necessarily more quickly than walking, but more smoothly and with less effort. I just climb in, get driven there, and climb out again.

What would change about it if you covered it in bronze?

It would be splendidly shiny, polished to a fine gleam, not just an ordinary chariot for everyday journeys. And it would be much heavier, lumbering along slowly, hard for the poor horses to get it moving. It's not going to be nimble; you wouldn't want to use this one on the battlefield.

(This is one place where commentary might come in useful: this isn't a chariot of solid bronze, it's decorated with bronze - 'the conveyance of the aristocrat' according to Stephen Field.)

You'll notice I'm not asking any questions about the conversation I might or might not start, or the decision that needs making. All I'm doing is digging more deeply into the image itself.

Also, you might be noticing that my answers aren't the ones you would give. Two people asking themselves about the same image will come up with different answers, and this is OK - in fact, it's the whole point. Your bronzed chariot might feel luxurious; mine seems to be a bit of a bone-rattler. Mine feels passive; you might be driving. That inner experience each of us has is the reading happening.

And at some point, as you imagine yourself into the image, you will probably have something of an 'aha!' moment.

Even then, this is not your cue to do a 'find and replace' operation on your reading, inserting 'take it slow' in place of the bronze chariot, or the one applying the brakes in 64.2.

I included those two lines because they might both be interpreted as 'take it slow', but they feel completely different. There's the effort of getting the heavy vehicle moving - and there's applying the drag so your wheels don't spin out of control down the bank into the river. If you keep the sound and motion of the chariot, or the smell of the river mud, present to your imagination, then you can take that whole subtle inner experience with you into the conversation. The trouble with taking away only the advice to 'go slow' is that you can understand 'go slow' completely: it makes sense. A vehicle careening down the bank towards the river does more than make sense.

More on this here - and in the 'Connecting with Imagery' workshop, which walks you through more examples and more ways of connecting.

I Ching Community

Podcast



Join Clarity

You are warmly invited to join Clarity and –

  • access the audio version of the Beginners’ Course
  • participate in the I Ching Community
  • subscribe to ‘Friends’ Notes’ for I Ching news