Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
- Joined
- May 29, 2006
- Messages
- 31,003
- Reaction score
- 6,470
Here's a new thread for Tuck's questions which were originally posted in the Unchanging Castings Hexagram 11 thread. Tuck agreed seems a good idea to have a thread for questions raised on those threads.
Tuck said
From my POV I'm not looking to follow anyone's experience, I merely want to hear it, hear how it was subjectively for them whether their experience was 'positive' or 'negative', and we know how misleading those terms can be since the worst experience can often bring about the most positive change and so on. I expect that there would be very different experiences naturally. I do not experience unchanging hexagram only one way and don't imagine anyone else does.....but a collection of experiences of the unchanging hexagrams as experienced subjectively I feel would be helpful .
If anyone finds the idea of these threads really questionable, unhelpful or pointless or whatever you think here is a special thread just to debate that ...I've just used your post Tuck to start it
BTW the issue of looking for consensus has arisen but thats not the point of the threads IMO since I expected there to be many different views. If many have similar expereinces of course connections can be made as would happen in any discussion on any hexagram or line we have ever discussed on the forum.
Yup I'm firmly in the Yi as 'spiritual' camp and don't understand at all why anyone would want to 'secularise' it as discussed in the de mythologising thread....anyway not so interested in discussing that. I don't mind what people think Yi is really, it doesn't matter to me.
I think everyone has 'magic power', I think every human being certainly has a 'magic tortoise' and I think there is still so much more to know academically and experientially about Yi it is good to continue exploring all of the ways possible. One of these ways is for people to be able to relate their subjective experiences of unchanging castings for example.
If someone starts to lecture me now about what the I Ching actually is, after I have been consulting it since 1977, I'm not really going to be taking their word for it. I have my own ideas and I think it is a very living oracle.
There are many threads to say for example hexagram 12 is like this or like that....and many threads to discuss issues such as you have raised, but it seemed a good idea of Arabellas to have a set of threads more or less centred around experiences of unchanging castings.....hence continuing with it. I am still saying it is like this or like that since experience and ideas cannot be separated anyway. But as you agreed your thoughts here do deserve a separate thread so you have the space to discuss the points you raised and other things.
The unchanging castings threads may be dead in the water anyway but I thought i'd make a new thread as we discussed :bows:
Tuck said
Dear Trojan,
I do agree with you to start another thread. My question will be: shall we follow the good experiences here, or the bad experiences? how shall we do if our defining hex sometimes turns out to be positive and sometimes negative?……. Additionally I would like to ask: who shall guide us to a right hexagram or line to our question? ……..shall we take the meaning best suited to our wish by wondering the text or the images occurring to us? … …….what is the attitude we should have when we receive advice? or, shall we take divination just to find out what is the inside and outside of ourselves?
From my POV I'm not looking to follow anyone's experience, I merely want to hear it, hear how it was subjectively for them whether their experience was 'positive' or 'negative', and we know how misleading those terms can be since the worst experience can often bring about the most positive change and so on. I expect that there would be very different experiences naturally. I do not experience unchanging hexagram only one way and don't imagine anyone else does.....but a collection of experiences of the unchanging hexagrams as experienced subjectively I feel would be helpful .
If anyone finds the idea of these threads really questionable, unhelpful or pointless or whatever you think here is a special thread just to debate that ...I've just used your post Tuck to start it
BTW the issue of looking for consensus has arisen but thats not the point of the threads IMO since I expected there to be many different views. If many have similar expereinces of course connections can be made as would happen in any discussion on any hexagram or line we have ever discussed on the forum.
I want to stress here: I do believe the existence of the secret power thanks to two experiences with the so-called spirit and my study of Ba Zi, but I don’t have it. Therefore I count on the I Ching when I divine, and the philosophy of Chinese numerology.
Yup I'm firmly in the Yi as 'spiritual' camp and don't understand at all why anyone would want to 'secularise' it as discussed in the de mythologising thread....anyway not so interested in discussing that. I don't mind what people think Yi is really, it doesn't matter to me.
To make me more clear in respect to divination by the I Ching. The hexagram is just a set of symbols. Zhou Yi provides each hexagram with a name and texts. Ten Wings is the one which defines Yin, Yang, heaven, earth, wind, thunder, and ….. according to the study of Zhou Yi, and converts the natural phenomenon into the appropriate human behaviors at each hexagram. I am trying to seek the true significance of the I Ching. No matter whether it is called a purely academic study or only a concept, I take it as a basis and trust it. AS to whether I take action, it is up to me.
If one has a chance to read the inscription on the tortoise’s shell, one might find a question of which late king I irritated and makes me toothache, and the answer (by its crack and by the diviner’s paraphrase): your grandfather. I don’t have that magic power.
Best regards
Tuck
I think everyone has 'magic power', I think every human being certainly has a 'magic tortoise' and I think there is still so much more to know academically and experientially about Yi it is good to continue exploring all of the ways possible. One of these ways is for people to be able to relate their subjective experiences of unchanging castings for example.
If someone starts to lecture me now about what the I Ching actually is, after I have been consulting it since 1977, I'm not really going to be taking their word for it. I have my own ideas and I think it is a very living oracle.
There are many threads to say for example hexagram 12 is like this or like that....and many threads to discuss issues such as you have raised, but it seemed a good idea of Arabellas to have a set of threads more or less centred around experiences of unchanging castings.....hence continuing with it. I am still saying it is like this or like that since experience and ideas cannot be separated anyway. But as you agreed your thoughts here do deserve a separate thread so you have the space to discuss the points you raised and other things.
The unchanging castings threads may be dead in the water anyway but I thought i'd make a new thread as we discussed :bows:
