Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
I asked this question last Sunday morning (10:30 a.m. EST) before Katrina actually hit land. At the time, they thought it would hit smack dab on New Orleans, very possibly at Category 5 strength. As it turned out it hit ever so slightly to the east at Category 4 strength.
Q: "What effect will Hurricane Katrina have on New Orleans?"
A: 29, Dangerously Deep, lines 4 and 5, changing to 40, Liberation
Line 4:
"A jug of wine, a bowl of rice with it;
Earthen vessels simply handed in through the window. There certainly is no blame in this."
Line 5:
"The abyss is not filled to overflowing, It is filled only to the rim. No blame."
Hexagram 29
Okay, this by itself makes sense (water over water, The Abysmal, Dangerously Deep). Perfect description.
But Hexagram 40, Deliverance/Liberation?
Well, people certainly have been 'liberated' all right - from their homes, businesses, loved ones...we've all been 'liberated' from an historical, unique, and beautiful city. But isn't this hexagram usually used in the sense of liberation as a GOOD thing, that you'd feel relieved about? As in, 'Yippee, school's out!'? Hardly the case here.
Yes, New Orleans has a decadent side. My own opinion is that we maybe can allow a place on this huge planet for Mardi Gras? - and besides, that's not all it was. People who think it was Satan's playground, entirely irredeemable, and deserved exactly what it got...well, I don't agree, it's my post and I'm not talkin' to you
, and you're probably not on this board to begin with.
(Well, okay,
to be fair and a better discussion-mate, if that is honestly what you think, and more to the point what you think Yi is saying, please do say so...)
Hex 29 Line 4:
Fair enough. A good description of what's happening with food, shelter, and other basic necessities. (Well, right this second it's NOT so much happening, but it will.)
Hex 29 Line 5:
Excuse me?! I suppose this is technically correct; if New Orleans is the 'abyss' into which the lake, the river, and the Gulf of Mexico is pouring, it can only fill up so far, to an equilibrium level. Duuuh.
But considering I asked this question Sunday morning - I think a Gallup poll would have thought that this meant the part where Katrina DID NOT hit the city head on at full strength, that it would NOT be as bad as possible, whew.
Especially since the translation I was using said for this line: "The dark waters of this pit will rise no higher. Your greatest danger now lies in panic. Keep your wits and you will escape."
Especially ALSO in conjunction with hexagram 40.
Which, of course, is NOT AT ALL what ultimately happened!
Now I do realize that the absolute worst of it was not technically Katrina, it was the levees bursting.
I also realize that the relatively reassuring interpretation WAS true at the time I did the reading.
However, I think this is a mighty fine line for Yi to be drawing with line 5 and hexagram 40. If I'd tried such an oh-so-clever use of the dictionary and the clock with my mother, I'd have been emphatically told to stop being a smart-aleck.
Okay, this post is obviously a l'il one-sided rant at Yi. But there's always a different way to look at it - particularly when it involves me trying to interpret the I Ching (and me being rant-y
). Just because I have a bad opinion of the reading right now doesn't mean my mind can't be changed (it's happened quite often with readings!) - and no matter what, it might be a good reading to learn from, since it's a news story and we objectively know what's going on and so forth.
So what do the rest of you make of it?
(BTW, I have no personal ties to New Orleans at all, wasn't motivated that way, just did the reading out of curiousity while watching TV coverage.)
Q: "What effect will Hurricane Katrina have on New Orleans?"
A: 29, Dangerously Deep, lines 4 and 5, changing to 40, Liberation
Line 4:
"A jug of wine, a bowl of rice with it;
Earthen vessels simply handed in through the window. There certainly is no blame in this."
Line 5:
"The abyss is not filled to overflowing, It is filled only to the rim. No blame."
Hexagram 29
Okay, this by itself makes sense (water over water, The Abysmal, Dangerously Deep). Perfect description.
But Hexagram 40, Deliverance/Liberation?
Well, people certainly have been 'liberated' all right - from their homes, businesses, loved ones...we've all been 'liberated' from an historical, unique, and beautiful city. But isn't this hexagram usually used in the sense of liberation as a GOOD thing, that you'd feel relieved about? As in, 'Yippee, school's out!'? Hardly the case here.
Yes, New Orleans has a decadent side. My own opinion is that we maybe can allow a place on this huge planet for Mardi Gras? - and besides, that's not all it was. People who think it was Satan's playground, entirely irredeemable, and deserved exactly what it got...well, I don't agree, it's my post and I'm not talkin' to you
(Well, okay,
Hex 29 Line 4:
Fair enough. A good description of what's happening with food, shelter, and other basic necessities. (Well, right this second it's NOT so much happening, but it will.)
Hex 29 Line 5:
Excuse me?! I suppose this is technically correct; if New Orleans is the 'abyss' into which the lake, the river, and the Gulf of Mexico is pouring, it can only fill up so far, to an equilibrium level. Duuuh.
But considering I asked this question Sunday morning - I think a Gallup poll would have thought that this meant the part where Katrina DID NOT hit the city head on at full strength, that it would NOT be as bad as possible, whew.
Especially since the translation I was using said for this line: "The dark waters of this pit will rise no higher. Your greatest danger now lies in panic. Keep your wits and you will escape."
Especially ALSO in conjunction with hexagram 40.
Which, of course, is NOT AT ALL what ultimately happened!
Now I do realize that the absolute worst of it was not technically Katrina, it was the levees bursting.
I also realize that the relatively reassuring interpretation WAS true at the time I did the reading.
However, I think this is a mighty fine line for Yi to be drawing with line 5 and hexagram 40. If I'd tried such an oh-so-clever use of the dictionary and the clock with my mother, I'd have been emphatically told to stop being a smart-aleck.
Okay, this post is obviously a l'il one-sided rant at Yi. But there's always a different way to look at it - particularly when it involves me trying to interpret the I Ching (and me being rant-y
So what do the rest of you make of it?
(BTW, I have no personal ties to New Orleans at all, wasn't motivated that way, just did the reading out of curiousity while watching TV coverage.)