Anyone had the same experience and is wondering??

[nykkic]

When I draw a Hexagram with one changing line the message is always clear... well of course it is ... now when I draw a Hexagram with TWO changing lines I often experienced that the original and the resulting Hexagram hit the nail on the head and were very true BUT the 2 changing lines were not and were not of value/had no message .. is it possible that with 2 changing lines one should only read the original and the resulting hexagram sometimes/or always?? ... can that be?? Same goes with 3 or more changing lines by the way ..

so my results were 100% correct when

1 changing line = I read the changing line and resulting Hexagram

2 changing lines= I read the original Hexagram and the resulting Hexagram (NOT the changing lines cos that did not seem to work)

3 or more changing lines = same .. original and resulting Hexagram


this is how it worked for me and made sense


opinions??

 

[Trojina]

Hexagram with TWO changing lines I often experienced that the original and the resulting Hexagram hit the nail on the head and were very true BUT the 2 changing lines were not and were not of value/had no message ..

I'd be very wary of the idea that you know what had no value/no message. Its not a fortune tellling kit and talk of 'accurate results' in terms of fortune telling always makes me squirm. There never is a 'result' it's always ongoing.

 

[nykkic]

I re-read a couple of reading concerning my career low 2 - 2 1/2 years ago and the original and resulting hexagrams I received way back then made perfect sense when I look at them now ... the 2 moving lines totally did not make sense though ... and that is only one example where that happened .. which is why I am very confused about 2 or more moving lines and how to read right now

 

[Trojina]

well re reading your first post yes i think you have a point. yes i have had similar experiences.

What you are saying is with one line moving it's pretty clear, when there's more than one line moving the story between the 2 hexagrams seems far more relevant overall. for me the more moving lines the more true this is so with 5 moving lines i really wouldn't bother to analyse them all. Two moving lines though I generally do look at both though as you say sometimes the answer is clearly spelled out in the picture the 2 hexes make.

An example that always comes to mind was when i asked if i should take a course and got 25.2.6>58. if I had hovered around trying to look for the problem in 25.6 I may not have done it but the hexes made a good sentence...so I did and it was nothing but fun in sharing. However I still think it pays to keep your eyes on the lines, they often show developments in a situation in a progressive time frame that's not noticeable for some time. So although you think you had the whole story for the reading several years ago perhaps it hasn't actually all played out yet.

So i'd still be wary of dismissing their relevance ....many situations have many components and the lines show that. In the end probably best to play it by ear, by what seems best to you at the time rather than making a rule for yourself about it.

I think when people laboriously go through line by line in interpretation and scarcely glance at the story the primary and relating hexagram make they tend to miss the main point of the answer but nevertheless the relevance of the line will be there somewhere

 

[nykkic]

so maybe it's like this with 2 moving lines:

original Hexagram = situation now

resulting Hexagram = where the situation will go to


2 moving lines = explanation of what happens on the way to the resulting situation ?????