Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).
Time to integrate those bad experiences, learn from them and move on. Being angry all the time shows you need to work on it to regain a sense of perspective. IMO.
I don't know of any Christian who use the Yijing. I think it would be difficult because God wants a Christian to put all his trust in Him. As Jesus said,"I am the Way, the Truth and the Life", so why bother with the Yijing?
Not sure if I've been of any help. At the moment I've had an experience of God's love, which I'm trying to understand, so the Yijing seems rather boring in comparison.
Bob
it seems to me that there are cristians making divination
(not just personal one, they also adress themsleves to magicians and things like this)
but maybe this is going on just in italy
!
I have personal faith
. In what may I ask. Personal faith is always in something is it not? Do you mean faith in yourself? In which case we all do. It's the same as saying that you value and trust yourself.
The bible has been on and off with divination. In the old testament they seemed to divine quite happily. But when they tell anyone to kill witches, I am happy I have the Yi. A lack of moral seems to hold more of my kind of moral than an overdose like this quote.the bible forbids divination (punishments going on for this) and adds : "you will not leave a single witch alive, nor their temples standying".
. Pure hysteria. How is this comment applicable to all Christians? It could be levelled at some of the replies to this thread. The wall of faith surrounding the Yijing can be just as defensive. Calm rational thinking never harmed anyone.I recognize that it's impossible to penetrate that wall of faith which can cocoon believers.
. To a large extent I agree with this. However I am reminded that only God has the ability to judge objectively and without bias. Like Yijing practitioners, there's a wide divergence of opinion and beliefs amongst the "faithful" so who knows what's really good or bad?I also believe the practice of modern day Christianity is quite likely so far removed from anything Jesus taught that he wouldn't even recognize it as being associated with him or his teaching. When Jesus returns to judge in Revelations, he returns to judge the seven churches, not the Yijing forums.
.The bible has been on and off with divination. In the old testament they seemed to divine quite happily. But when they tell anyone to kill witches, I am happy I have the Yi.
.Well i don't know much about the bible but it seems full of divination to me. Who were the 3 wise men if they were not diviners, astrologers in fact. Theres loads of instances of divination in the bible, signs, omens and so on.
Agreed. If you read my post I never implied there weren't any.Just becasue you don't know any christians who consult the Yi doesn't mean there aren't any.
I was trying to explain that a Christian may well get a sense of meeting God, and receiving God's love through reading the bible. I am not aware of the same experience happening with the Yijing. I did not imply that people who use the Yijing don't have spiritual lives. But as with any god based religion, the characteristics of the gods vary.Re the Gods love comment, are you saying that people who use the Yi don't know Gods love If the Yi Jing seems so boring why are you spending all this time on an I Ching forum talking about it ? Just wondering ....
Prayer being a direct contact between the person and God. Given the fact one can talk with God, why would you want to consult the Yijing?
IMHO, that begs for some questions: Who's to say God is not on the other side of the Yijing, sans the heavy weight of institutionalized dogma? Isn't consulting the Yijing a sort of prayer for a favorable outcome? Who can, irrefutably, deny that one is not talking to "God," as conceived by many monotheistic religions, when consulting the Yijing?
This is a rather insidious comment on Christian beliefs. Which Christians' belief are you referring to? Quakers, Pentecostals, Episcopaleans? There seems plenty of institutional dogma surrounding the Yijing. Witness your responses to threads, and Bradford's too. There are plenty of other examples within this forum. Christians aren't the only dogmatists.heavy weight of institutionalized dogma
I suppose it could be if you considered the Yijing to be some sort of living spirit. However I was under the impression that Daoist spirits had been exorcised from the book and it was now a twentieth century form of divination. If you insist that it does have spirits, then compared to monotheistic religions they are very limited in their scope.Isn't consulting the Yijing a sort of prayer for a favorable outcome?
. Once again I'm not in a position to state any certainties. However, compared to prayer, as talking to God, it is very constrained and doesn't include the other "direction" of prayer, namely when God wants to talk to you. In fact it isn't really like prayer at all. You can't confess your "sins" or ask forgiveness when you screw up. You can't express your concern about other people and pray for healing. You can't express your joy to your God for a beautiful spring morning. Consulting the Yijing as a spiritual exercise, OK but nothing like prayer.Who can, irrefutably, deny that one is not talking to "God,"
. The bible is complex. To understand it in any depth one needs to look to biblical experts to unwrap ancient meanings, myths and theologies much like understanding the Yijing. There are few signs and omens in the gospels apart from the obvious one of Jesus, who was a sign from God. I, for one, take a modern position with regard to the birth stories: not historical facts but mythical expressions of faith. There are innumerable books about interpreting the bible but few people bother, including Christians. Again, just like the Yijing, you really need to have read and studied it before making superficial assertions. It cannot be picked up and understood like a school text book, nor can the Yijing.
Bob:bows:
I was trying to explain that a Christian may well get a sense of meeting God, and receiving God's love through reading the bible. I am not aware of the same experience happening with the Yijing. I did not imply that people who use the Yijing don't have spiritual lives. But as with any god based religion, the characteristics of the gods vary.
Yahweh, the God of the Jews and Christians is not the same as Zeus or Hecate, favoured by the Pagans. Both may experience similarities in how they experience their deities, but there would also be extreme divergencies.
If you read my other comments you will see that I said I feel I'm at a crossroad with my "spiritual" life. You will also note that I said a follower of Jesus can get answers to problems through reading the bible and prayer. Prayer being a direct contact between the person and God. Given the fact one can talk with God, why would you want to consult the Yijing?
Bob :bows:
Jesus's parables are not kiddies stories. They are clever and sophisticated, more like zen koans, designed to halt the listener in his tracks and get him to see in a different way. They are paradoxical pointers to the "Kingdom of God".Jesus' parables were made for ease of understanding not for academics...
well one can't keep bothering God with questions like "where are my keys" or "shall I buy this camera or that camera".... besides shes pretty slow to respond to these kind of queries though next time i lose my keys I'll try asking her....though i doubt she'll be interested....
People may feel encouraged, relieved and happier after an Yijing consultation. If they feel God's love, where is the God that cause of that love, for he/she/it is not indicated or revealed in the Yijing? Similarly with feeling understood. Does the Yijing ever discuss an individual's need to be understood or indicate that this is one of its functions?Mm actually i think many people do feel Gods love through consulting the Yi though they may not call it that, they feel answered and understood by some broader intelligence.
Hi Pantherpanther, it's not often that one sees a quote from the King James version these days. However I'm not too sure what point you're making? Can you clarify.
The debate about what came first ends up in futility. The very definition of "God" is the prime causation, the beginning. Word play is for TV pundits who have nothing better to do. The important thing is always what does your following your "religious path" do to you and the world around you? By their fruits, after all.
Bob:bows:
Hi Trojan, as I said before, people should read and understand the bible before they try and make a point.
Jesus's parables are not kiddies stories. They are clever and sophisticated, more like zen koans, designed to halt the listener in his tracks and get him to see in a different way. They are paradoxical pointers to the "Kingdom of God".
If that's what you use the Yijing for, that's your choice but it seems to be missing the point somewhat.
People may feel encouraged, relieved and happier after an Yijing consultation. If they feel God's love, where is the God that cause of that love, for he/she/it is not indicated or revealed in the Yijing? Similarly with feeling understood. Does the Yijing ever discuss an individual's need to be understood or indicate that this is one of its functions?
In contrast the bible does go on about relations with God, understanding, needs and wants. The psalms are classic examples of pouring out one's soul to God.
Bob:bows:
. The quote refers to a child's trust, i.e. we are to trust in Jesus and what he says, does and offers. That is we become converted to his way and therefore enter the Kingdom. Parables are not for children but for adults asking what is the kindom like, where is it and how do I enter it.Matthew 18.3 "Verily I say unto you, Except ye be converted and become as little children, ye shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven"..
You have mistaken me here. I didn't say read the whole bible. I think very, very few Christians have, as it's a massive tome. What I tried to indicate is you should read at least the gospels, perhaps with an upto date commentry, to see what Jesus was all about. School religious instruction lessons are not where it's at. It may be even better to talk with some practising Christians who actually follow their beliefs. We've all been brought up in a nominally Christian culture, but it bears little relationship to the faith of a believer.I have to say I take exception to you telling me i may not comment on this thread unless i have read the entire bible
I think Hilary, the owner of this site is Christian, or was, at least i thought she said she was once. Also I think Rosada, an active I Ching user here is (apologies to both if i am wrong) I myself am pretty open to Christianity..because here in UK the kind of christianity i have come across in my upbringing was just about not hurting people and tolerance and so on...nothing about damnation etc etc and I've never come across any fundamental full on types so don't connect them with my sense of Christianity at all..Just becasue you don't know any christians who consult the Yi doesn't mean there aren't any.
According to Laozi, Tao exists before the concept of God (Ti).
Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).