Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).
Hexagram: 52 "Ken (Keeping Still, Mountain)"
Judgment: "Keeping Still, Mountain. Keeping his back still So that he no longer feels his body. He goes into his courtyard And does not see his people. No blame."
Line 52.1: "Keeping his toes still. No blame. Continued perseverance furthers."
Line 52.2: "Keeping his calves still. He cannot rescue him whom he follows. His heart is not glad."
Line 52.3: "Keeping his hips still. Making his lower back stiff. Dangerous. The heart suffocates."
Line 52.4: "Keeping his trunk still. No blame."
Line 52.5: "Keeping his jaws still. The words have order. Remorse disappears."
Line 52.6: "Noblehearted keeping still. Good fortune."
Image 52: "Mountain resting on its base: the image of Keeping Still. Thus the superior man does not permit his thoughts to go beyond his situation."
A little bit more of a technical computer code massage, I take it, rather than 400 ish individual copy and pastes.BTW, I'm massaging the PDF to extract the text, I'll let you know when I'll be able to use it with GPT4.
Quite so I've done it. See next post for comparisonA little bit more of a technical computer code massage, I take it, rather than 400 ish individual copy and pastes.
Yishi (based on Whilelm translation): Full reading
Summary:
Your desire to travel and study abroad is timely and aligned with a phase of growth (Hexagram 42). It's important to act on these aspirations while being considerate and kind towards your family (42.5). Self-reflection and sincerity in your intentions will be crucial. You are encouraged to persevere in your efforts, as this will lead to success and good fortune, especially in endeavors that take you across great distances (Hexagram 27). Remember, kindness and a genuine heart, along with self-awareness and sincerity, are your guiding principles in this journey.
Yinxing (based on Hatcher's translation): Full reading
Summary:
Your reading, combining hexagrams 42 and 27, with the changing line 42.5, advises you to embrace opportunities for growth and change with sincerity and kindness. It suggests that your current focus on financial recovery and family concerns is part of a journey towards personal growth and nourishment. The advice is to persist in your endeavors, as this will lead you to the fulfillment of your aspirations to travel or study abroad. Trust in the value of opportunities that come your way and approach them with a true and kind heart, as this attitude will guide you to make the most of them.
I took as an example a question from Reddit (I wanted to check if the response was more or less in line with the comments written there) and here is the readings I got with the two translations. I'll report just the summaries here for a quick comparison, look at the full reading to see the different translations in action.
Question: I wanted to go to other places but right now I am just recovering financially and I am also worried about my family if I leave them. What can I do to be able to travel/study abroad?
Answer: 42.5
Yishi (Whilelm): Full reading
I'm going to sound dim, I don't mind, but what is this ? Neither commentaries you've quoted seem to have any connection to the commentaries of the authors. Did you feed them into AI and it mashed their commentaries up to this ? If so then it just made a sort of rather bland smoothie coverall of an answer IMO.I took as an example a question from Reddit (I wanted to check if the response was more or less in line with the comments written there) and here is the readings I got with the two translations. I'll report just the summaries here for a quick comparison, look at the full reading to see the different translations in action.
Question: I wanted to go to other places but right now I am just recovering financially and I am also worried about my family if I leave them. What can I do to be able to travel/study abroad?
Answer: 42.5
Yishi (Whilelm): Full reading
....so I'm wondering why you've put this under his name and it's not to his credit that it's under his name because he didn't write such bland coverall stuff, his writing was far more spicy. Have I missed something crucial? What I'm seeing is Bradford's name over something I don't think Bradford would ever have written and I don't get it ? Bradford's work is so unique and individual to him, his little stories for commentaries on each line, it's very recognisable.Your reading, combining hexagrams 42 and 27, with the changing line 42.5, advises you to embrace opportunities for growth and change with sincerity and kindness. It suggests that your current focus on financial recovery and family concerns is part of a journey towards personal growth and nourishment. The advice is to persist in your endeavors, as this will lead you to the fulfillment of your aspirations to travel or study abroad. Trust in the value of opportunities that come your way and approach them with a true and kind heart, as this attitude will guide you to make the most of them.
Thanks, Sparhawk, but I don't like the translation from Legge much. It's not that I've studied it much but every time I looked at it, it does not resonate with me (contrary to the Hatcher translation or the Takashima Ekidan, which I liked).If I may, I would suggest you get a copy of Legge's translation. It isn't as bad as many would like to appraise and it is in the public domain, unlike Wilhelm's.
Hi @Trojina, i'm not generating commentaries, the experiment is to generate reading by interpreting the hexagrams text. I never said that those where Bradford's or Wilhelm's commentaries, but that the interpretaion was done using their translation. I gave no indication to the AI that the generated text should mimic any style or particular author.I'm going to sound dim but I don't mind but what is this ? Neither commentaries you've quoted seem to have any connection to the commentaries of the authors. Did you feed them into AI and it mashed their commentaries up to this ? If so then it just made a sort of rather bland smoothie coverall of an answer IMO.
What connection has that commentary got to Bradford, he didn't write like this....
Prompted by a post on Reddit, I explored the possibility of making a GPT able to produce plausible I Ching readings in response to a question. I created a custom GPT that generates hexagrams with the three-coins probability (you know how much I care about knowing the probability distribution of each method) and uses the Wilhelm translation as the basis for the interpretation.
Yes, I used the word 'commentary' for the readings I guess because they came across as more like commentaries being generic, not tailored to an individual human situation. And you are only using their translations not their commentaries to generate these ? Hmm. I guess seeing Brad's name by that reading just struck me as so not Brad I'd wonder why his name was there at all. Well I know you are crediting using his translation but seeing the reading and his name by it just, well, it really isn't Brad like IMO but I guess it wasn't meant to be.Hi @Trojina, i'm not generating commentaries, the experiment is to generate reading by interpreting the hexagrams text. I never said that those where Bradford's or Wilhelm's commentaries, but that the interpretaion was done using their translation.
Yes, the base for the generated text is their translation of the judgment, the image, and the changing lines, nothing else.And you are only using their translations not their commentaries to generate these ? Hmm. I guess seeing Brad's name by that reading just struck me as so not Brad I'd wonder why his name was there at all.
Yes, I used the word 'commentary' for the readings I guess because they came across as more like commentaries being generic, not tailored to an individual human situation.
why do you see this not related to an individual situation? What kind of reference to the original question would you have considered more related to the question itself? Or, maybe, do you feel that interpretation of 42.5 with respect to the question is incorrect (miss the point, focus on the wrong part of the text, ...)?Your desire to travel and study abroad is timely and aligned with a phase of growth (Hexagram 42). It's important to act on these aspirations while being considerate and kind towards your family (42.5).
Well it fails in that it's just not human is it and it showsI'm exactly interested in understanding where the AI fails in this respect.
It sounds like it's computer generated, it's not addressing the human being.why do you see this not related to an individual situation? What kind of reference to the original question would you have considered more directed to the question?
Yes! But how does it show it? What makes it sound "computer generated"?Well it fails in that it's just not human is it and it shows
It sounds like it's computer generated, it's not addressing the human being.
Sorry, I didn't mean "42.5" as "the fifth line of 42" but as a shorthand for "42.5 > 27", the full response.I don't much agree with the 'reading' anyway, 42.5 does not say that it is very 'important to act on aspirations'
As a side note, I have to say that, for me, the dialogue with the I Ching is very personal and is something that I developed over many years. I rarely do readings for others because I believe that the response is fully meaningful only for the person who posed the question. If I had to do for others (like sometimes I was asked) I always warn them that what I can provide is just a generic, biased response, based on my limited comprehension of what's really going on.Also there's no reader interacting with the querent and without that it's just empty.
That's the post:Is there a link to the Reddit thread? I wouldn't mind seeing what actual people came up with and if there was more back-and-forth with the querent.
It's kind of a hand-wavy line...how one would go about leaving one's family to travel while still being benevolent towards them, and doing all of this with fu...I'd have no idea and would want to dig in more probably.
There's nothing there a human wouldn't say it's just an impression. It's quite hard to define why it sounds computer generated. Rereading I suppose it sounds a bit dead. Perhaps it is something to do with texture, the sense of the person talking to you. The generated text reminds me of those horoscopes in newspapersYes! But how does it show it? What makes it sound "computer generated"?
I'm not a native English speaker, so I might miss the point where it clearly says something that a human wouldn't say.
Come to think of it what has 27 got to do with great distances ? No one speaks like that. It's not that anyone couldn't say it but it just sounds mechanical like reading a newspaper horoscope.Self-reflection and sincerity in your intentions will be crucial. You are encouraged to persevere in your efforts, as this will lead to success and good fortune, especially in endeavors that take you across great distances (Hexagram 27)
Yes I know you were giving the reading of 42.5>27 but I was just saying I wouldn't necessarily read 42.5 that way. There's so many factors in the question and Yi replies 'If you have a kind heart, ask not...' (Wilhelm I think) it's basically approving your motives, saying your heart is so true in this you need not worry. What if this person has people to care for at home? Well then this line would be maybe saying that their goodness in staying superseded their ambitions. It could be encouraging them to travel and study abroad but I think as Liselle said more input would be needed from them before being sure it was 'yes go ahead'.Sorry, I didn't mean "42.5" as "the fifth line of 42" but as a shorthand for "42.5 > 27", the full response.
it seems to me that this response to the question "What can I do to be able to travel/study abroad?" is a positive one and that it encourages the querent to pursue to persevere in his effort to move abroad
Do you mean you took readings from SR here over there ? Or do you mean you have done AI readings in SR ? I can't see that you have done many readings in SR.I must confess I've done the some for some question on the "Shared readings" section here on Clarity to see if the AI generated readings were substantially different from the human comments. I thought it was disrespectful to jump in the discussion there, since, I believe, this topic of AI generated readings is better discussed here in "Exploring divination".
Oh no, this is exactly the type of feedback I was looking for! Thank you......but it is a field I know nothing about so don't mind me.
I mean I generate the AI reading and look at the general direction comparing it to the answer on the forum. I never posted them, I would never offer a generated reading without warning.Do you mean you took readings from SR here over there ? Or do you mean you have done AI readings in SR ? I can't see that you have done many readings in SR.
Legge's translation is idiosyncratic to him and the environment around him and the times in which he was working. No more idiosyncratic than McClatchie writing around the same time or Wilhelm some 40 years later. They are just different. It's just a question of 'Which Ben and Jerry's flavour do you prefer?'If I may, I would suggest you get a copy of Legge's translation. It isn't as bad as many would like to appraise and it is in the public domain, unlike Wilhelm's.
I rarely do readings for others because I believe that the response is fully meaningful only for the person who posed the question. If I had to do for others (like sometimes I was asked) I always warn them that what I can provide is just a generic, biased response, based on my limited comprehension of what's really going on.
So, I lack this notion of interaction between the reader and the querent, probably this is another reason I find difficult to judge the AI generated readings.
An image would make it more readable, but we need to accept compromises.Primary Hexagram 16 "䷏ YU4, READINESS"
which, with the prompt "generate an image that summarizes the text above" created the following image:To help your partner with their work-related issues, foster a positive and energetic attitude, like the sun at its peak. Encourage them to face challenges decisively and be prepared for upcoming opportunities. A period of transformation may be necessary, so advise them to embrace change with faith and perseverance for successful outcomes.
Created a new GPTs with the Italian translation (ML from German, rephrased with chatGPT and adjusted manually).The next steps for me will be:
- Add a translation in Italian (I want to try in my own language) [DONE]
Clarity,
Office 17622,
PO Box 6945,
London.
W1A 6US
United Kingdom
Phone/ Voicemail:
+44 (0)20 3287 3053 (UK)
+1 (561) 459-4758 (US).